Are College Athletes Students or Employees?

College athletes’ position in sports gets debated almost daily these days. Young men and women are going into the world and competing for NCAA and their respective colleges. While it is excellent for young people to get out there and experience their dreams in full, there is a moral dilemma that must be addressed.

These college athletes are earning the colleges billions of dollars while receiving absolutely nothing in return. Sure, most of them will be there on scholarships, but that doesn’t even come close to what they deserve.

The question we have all been asking about is ‘should these college athletes still be considered students or should they be regarded as employees?’ We discuss more at March Athletic Club.

College Athletes are Being Used

The colleges are taking these young men and women out of their colleges and panting them in sports teams around the globe. You would think this would be great as they could get right into their careers but that isn’t so.

Everything would be fine if these college students were fairly compensated for their efforts. However, the colleges are pocketing millions of dollars a year without giving a penny to the ones who got it for them.

Amateurism Act Agreement of 1906

The actions of the NCAA are in direct violation of the Amsterdam Act Agreement of 1906. The coaches of these teams are using the scholarship agreement with the colleges to take the students out of school without much say from their professors.

A scholarship is a fantastic opportunity for anyone, but it isn’t right for these coaches to violate a century-old act that should still be enforced.

No one is certain why the government pays no heed to this obvious breach. The general opinion is that they are enjoying the flow of cash.

NCAA’s Blackmail Technique

The NCAA created a contractual agreement clause in 1967 that gave them full power to ‘fire’ a college student from their team and retract their scholarship agreement. They could do this at any time if the college student did not perform well enough.

There is no specific guideline for how the student should perform. The decision is entirely up to the coach in question. At the end of the day, any student who doesn’t earn the team a decent amount of money has a high chance of losing their scholarship.

So, now college students are forced to perform in the team to keep their scholarship without the benefit of any salary.


Obviously, a team should earn something from paying a scholarship to a college student. However, at this time college students are being treated like employees during their scholarship period.

The number of complaints and lost dreams from college athletes should point out the issue with the NCAA. Steps should be taken to ensure that student-athletes remain, students, not unpaid employees.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *